St. Petersburg Times
Special report
Video report
  • For their own good
    Fifty years ago, they were screwed-up kids sent to the Florida School for Boys to be straightened out. But now they are screwed-up men, scarred by the whippings they endured. Read the story and see a video and portrait gallery.
  • More video reports
Multimedia report
Print Email this storyEmail story Comment Email editor
Fill out this form to email this article to a friend
Your name Your email
Friend's name Friend's email
Your message
 

Police jail rape victim for two days

By REBECCA CATALANELLO
Published January 30, 2007


ADVERTISEMENT

TAMPA - First, police say, a 21-year-old woman was raped at Gasparilla. Then, she was handcuffed and jailed - for two nights and two days.

A jail worker with religious objections blocked her from ingesting a morning-after pill to prevent pregnancy, her attorney says, keeping her from taking the required second dose for more than 24 hours longer than recommended.

The Hillsborough Sheriff's Office wouldn't talk about her medical treatment in jail. But Tampa police are investigating why more compassion wasn't shown toward the woman after she reported her sexual assault to law enforcement.

"We may need to revisit our policy," police spokeswoman Laura McElroy said.

The premedical student attended Saturday's Gasparilla parade and veered off from her friends shortly before 1:30 p.m., police said. The Times is not naming her because police say she is a victim of a sexual crime.

As she walked north on Howard Avenue at Swann Avenue, she was grabbed by a man with crooked teeth and raped behind a building, McElroy said.

After the assault, the man ran off. The woman walked to her car, which was parked on the University of Tampa campus. At 3:40 p.m., after finding her vehicle, she called police.

As police assisted her, taking her to a nurse examiner's clinic, and processing her report, an officer found two outstanding warrants for the woman in Sarasota County.

Attorney Virlyn "Vic" Moore III of Venice said his client was seated in the front seat of the police cruiser, on her way to the scene of her attack when the officer learned of the warrant, cuffed her and placed her in the back seat.

"To stop the rape investigation and instead victimize her again," Moore said. "I'm aghast, astonished and outraged. I have never, ever heard of this happening."

The officer arrested the woman at a sergeant's instruction, McElroy said.

The student had failed to pay $4,585 restitution after a 2003 juvenile arrest, McElroy said. Moore said his client is convinced that she paid the fine and that the warrant was probably the result of a clerical error.

The judge set no bail.

"As soon as the chief's office found out about it Monday, detectives were assigned to get her out of jail," McElroy said. "Obviously, we're very concerned about this young woman."

Jail records show the woman was booked about eight hours after the reported rape.

A doctor had given her Plan B, the so-called "morning-after pill" approved by the FDA, to prevent pregnancy. But Moore said a medical supervisor at the jail refused to let her take the second of the two pills on Sunday.

For the emergency contraceptive to work, the first pill must be taken within three days of unprotected sex and the second 12 hours after the first. The woman had already taken the first pill soon after the assault Saturday, Moore said. She was unable to take the second pill until Monday afternoon. The jail allowed it, he said, after media inquiries.

Debbie Carter, a spokeswoman for the Sheriff's Office, which runs the jail, said she couldn't comment on the situation because medical information is private. But she said medical service policies are set by Armor Correctional Health Services, which contracts with the jail.

Armor's corporate offices were closed late Monday when the St. Petersburg Times tried to reach a spokesperson.

Police administrators learned about the woman's arrest Monday, McElroy said.

Moore worked with police to petition the court to reinstate the woman's bail so she could be freed. Jail records indicate the woman was released Monday at 5 p.m. Hillsborough Circuit Judge Walter Heinrich ordered the change in bail.

If the warrants had been for misdemeanors, the woman would not have been jailed, under a TPD policy enacted in 2002.

But she faced felony charges for failing to pay restitution, McElroy said.

"But we always have to balance that with compassion for the victim," McElroy said.

The rape suspect was described as a black man, 5-foot-7 to less than 6 feet tall, medium build with a dark complexion, in his mid 20s. He has a short Afro, brown eyes, a large flat nose and no facial hair. He was wearing a tan T-shirt and jeans.

Anyone with information is asked to call TPD at (813) 231-6130.

Times researcher John Martin contributed to this report. Rebecca Catalanello can be reached at rcatalanello@sptimes.com or (813) 226-3383.

[Last modified January 30, 2007, 00:48:02]


Share your thoughts on this story

Comments on this article
by kiki 01/22/08 07:45 PM
i dont care how many charges ahe had she still should not have went to jail. She was a rape victom and jail is just as bad as being rape.i think they should look into her rape case drop the charges and i personally think that she should sew them.
by c pettway 12/09/07 02:43 PM
this is very sad my prayers go out to this young lady sweet heart get therapy and a good lawyer
by publicblotter 09/25/07 04:16 AM
What ever happened to 'innocent until proven guilty' police departments are filled with stupid police with 3rd grade intelligence. 'What a bunch of idiots'. And guess what; we the people pay their salaries.
by Kara 09/11/07 10:51 AM
I think that the police should have taken her to the doctors first. What if she was preganant? wut would they have done. its ridiculious!! cops are discusting. and their suppose to help. Yeah Right.
by TJ 09/01/07 01:01 PM
This just goes to show what we value most rape or money,,
by Sheridan 08/23/07 08:23 AM
There's no excuse for what the police done to her. She's the victim why to handcuff and jailed her? This is so ridiculous!
by Chris 08/13/07 12:59 AM
This is disgusting. Its probably why I ride a street bike. All the better to keep away from those who do not serve and do not protect.
by rob 07/23/07 07:55 AM
"to serve and protect" our police, hard at work. I wonder if they had to rough her up too?
by tiffany 07/18/07 09:34 AM
this is retared because didnt the police mann rape her and what happend to him why did s he have to go to jail when she was raped and if she had A warrent that doesnt mean that she has to go to jail they should have given her more time to pay it
by borj 07/04/07 03:13 AM
i guess the police officers should have been re-oriented from time to time..they almost forgot their objectives which is to enforce law..the jutified law.
by Jane 07/02/07 09:44 PM
A cop in Texas that refused to taser someone who wasn't violent as he said it would violate his religious beliefs to do so was fired. Why isn't that happening in this case when the religion is inspiring HARMFUL, as opposed to beneficial, acts?
by Jimmy 04/18/07 06:35 AM
I sure hope this kind of treatment is an isolated incident and that the community does the right thing by ensuring that the police are there to protect and serve. Understand there are bad apples in every organization.
by Jimmy 04/18/07 06:26 AM
Religious beliefs are great and people should have them if they want. That said, this victim of rape and police brutality should have never been subject to jail, had access to the MAP by another employer if jailed, and should have complete F/U care.
by Valerie 04/12/07 11:45 AM
The police could have just as easily arrested her later, they already had her address for the rape investigation. Her medical treatment should have come first and NOT been subject to some religious nut forcing her opinion on the victim's body!
by cassandra 04/05/07 09:37 PM
absolutely ridiculous
by Tracy 03/30/07 12:21 PM
ABSOLUTE BULLOCKS! Disgusting. SICK to happen in THE USA!
by Samantha 03/13/07 01:13 PM
This is ABSURD and it happens everywhere EVERY DAY and noone does anything about it !
by mesha 02/25/07 04:54 AM
This story is heartbreaking... Criminalizing a rape victim , then preventing her fro avoiding a pregnency after assualt ? What century is this ?
by anita 02/25/07 01:25 AM
I think they should loose there jobs. This should be out in the news more to have those people who treated her like this put to shame and the young women should sue the city. The rapist is left out there to rape again.
by Janice 02/22/07 06:28 AM
It seems that "we the people" have lost our rights; it has been coming with this Bush Administration: such as the "Patriots' Act" and the loss of Habeus Corpus. And, whatever other decent law that would protect rather feed our "Police State.
by Kycowboy 02/21/07 08:08 PM
Yes American justic at their finest !!
by Lou 02/21/07 02:41 PM
What ever your religious beliefs are, that does not give you the right to decide for someone else. If the woman wanted the pill, she was justified in receiving it.
by Sandy 02/21/07 01:52 PM
This is so horrific, I feel nauseated. I'm hopeful they did a rape kit, though, since she got a scrip. Why exactly would you blame the states of TX and FL? Blame the narrow-minded morons who arrested her on a restitution warrant. Pray for compassion.
by Mike 02/12/07 06:46 PM
The policemen just applied the law. Is not it what is expected of them?
by Mike 02/09/07 11:04 PM
The nurse initally denied the religious reasons story. Am I correct?
by cil 02/08/07 04:10 AM
I am absolutly agast at the situation. To be jailed after rape- ThEN have your medication refused. Shocking. If she does get pregnant it should be the person who refused the treatment responsibity- all the baby costs. It was the jailor not nurse..?
by Max 02/07/07 02:40 PM
Hm, they put the rape victim in jail, and havent captured the rapist. Sound like an agency with little to show for its funding.
by BiancaRN 02/07/07 11:08 AM
Alex you're right. I have refused to carry out certain procedures but you better damn well believe I found someone else to give the care. The good news is only 5% of rapes result in pregnancy so the odds were in the victims favor.
by Cherri 02/06/07 10:45 PM
The big problem is that now any girl who has an outstanding traffic victim is the ideal rape victim - she'll be too afraid of being arrested herself to report the crime. Rapists are reading this report with glee - a little research nets perfect vic.
by Alex 02/06/07 02:49 PM
Im mad about the nurses refusal to administer the second pill!Since when do we get to infringe our own religious beliefs on others?The nurse should face reprimand!If she feels that her religion should be forced others,then she should join the Taliban
by Marie 02/05/07 07:03 PM
I feel for this poor girl. I became a victim almost 7 years ago and I don't know if I would have survived 2 days in jail immediately following what I experienced. Shame on everyone involved.
by Liz 02/05/07 05:05 PM
SP Times: write a story about who these people were! These police officials should be fired and lose their pensions!!! Then tarred and feathered!!!
by Shani 02/05/07 04:43 PM
THe article says the meds were allowed "äfter media inquiries". Forget the lawyer- hire a publicist. Since when is the media a substitute for conscience and compassion? A pre-med student too...sign the Planned Parenthood petition!
by Florianne 02/04/07 08:41 AM
Im aghast that this kind of victim treatment still exist at this day. What kind of society that we have today if the victim is the one that is arrested? That is just so sick....:(
by Alex 02/03/07 02:52 AM
Excuses, Excuses. Sounds like CYA on nurse's part. The nurse should still be FIRED ASAP & license revoked FOR LIFE. John, read the article again. 4 wks is outside parameters for the MAP. MAP & RU-486 are different. Tim, equating her w/ Bundy is SICK.
Subscribe to the Times
Click here for daily delivery
of the St. Petersburg Times.

Email Newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT