Make us your home page

Get the quickest, smartest news, analysis and photos from the Bucs game emailed to you shortly after the final whistle.

(View our Privacy Policy)

Ryan Fitzpatrick vs. Josh McCown: Comparing the vagabond quarterbacks

Ryan Fitzpatrick greets Josh McCown after the Jets beat the Browns 31-28 last season. [Getty Images]

Ryan Fitzpatrick greets Josh McCown after the Jets beat the Browns 31-28 last season. [Getty Images]

When the Buccaneers host the Jets on Sunday, it won't be the first time Ryan Fitzpatrick and Josh McCown have gone head-to-head. In fact, this will be the third straight season they've played against each other. Fitzpatrick's Jets got the better of McCown's Browns both times.

Okay, so it's not Brady vs. Manning. It's more like beige vs. khaki. Really.

See whether you can tell the difference.

Josh McPatrick or Ryan Fitzcown?

Their career stats are virtually indistinguishable.

Quarterback A Quarterback B
Win percentage 0.401 0.319
Completion percentage 59.8 60.4
Touchdown percentage 4.3 3.8
Interception percentage 3.4 3.2
Yards per attempt 6.7 6.8
Quarterback rating 79.9 80.2

(Answer: Quarterback A is Fitzpatrick, B is McCown)

How'd we get here?

Fitzpatrick and McCown have been all over the map. They've called 13 NFL cities home but haven't stayed anywhere longer than four seasons. Their former teams haven't missed them, but they haven't exactly been better off, either.


Team Seasons Who he replaced Who replaced him
St. Louis 2005-2006 Marc Bulger Marc Bulger
Cincinnati 2007-2008 Carson Palmer Carson Palmer
Buffalo 2009-2012 Trent Edwards EJ Manuel
Tennessee 2013 Jake Locker Jake Locker
Houston 2014 Matt Schaub Brian Hoyer
N.Y. Jets 2015-2016 Geno Smith Josh McCown
Tampa Bay 2017 Jameis Winston


Team Seasons Who he replaced Who replaced him
Arizona 2002-2005 Jeff Blake (2003), Kurt Warner (2005) Shaun King (2004), Kurt Warner (2005)
Detroit 2006 Did not attempt a pass.
Oakland 2007 Daunte Culpepper JaMarcus Russell
Carolina 2008-2009 Jake Delhomme Jake Delhomme
Played in United Football League in 2010.
Chicago 2011-2013 Jay Cutler Jay Cutler
Tampa Bay 2014 Mike Glennon Jameis Winston
Cleveland 2015-2016 Connor Shaw Austin Davis
N.Y. Jets 2017 Ryan Fitzpatrick

They're not eating Ws

The 20 lowest win percentages among active quarterbacks (minimum 16 games started):

Player Win%
Blaine Gabbert 0.225
Brandon Weeden 0.240
Mike Glennon 0.273
Colt McCoy 0.280
Terrelle Pryor 0.300
Blake Bortles 0.302
Josh McCown 0.319
EJ Manuel 0.333
Chad Henne 0.340
Kellen Clemens 0.381
Geno Smith 0.400
Ryan Fitzpatrick 0.401
Jameis Winston 0.425
Derek Anderson 0.426
Sam Bradford 0.431
Brian Hoyer 0.432
Case Keenum 0.433
Matt Cassel 0.444
Matthew Stafford 0.470
Marcus Mariota 0.471

Contact Thomas Bassinger at Follow @tometrics.


vs. Jets, 1, Raymond James Stadium

TV/radio: CBS; 97.9-FM

Line/OU: Jets by 2½; 43½

Ryan Fitzpatrick vs. Josh McCown: Comparing the vagabond quarterbacks 11/10/17 [Last modified: Sunday, November 12, 2017 11:44am]
Photo reprints | Article reprints

© 2017 Tampa Bay Times


Join the discussion: Click to view comments, add yours

  1. Buccaneers-Dolphins Turning Point, Week 11: Cool, calm Fitzmagic


    On Sunday, the Buccaneers and Dolphins played one of those football games that gets only an obligatory mention at the end of highlight shows. In that spirit, this week's Turning Point will focus mostly on the final three minutes of Bucs quarterback Ryan Fitzpatrick completed about 60 percent of his passes Sunday and threw for 275 yards in a 30-20 win over the Dolphins. He threw touchdown passes and no interceptions. [LOREN ELLIOTT | Times]

  2. 3-2-1, BAM! Watch the Georgia Dome being imploded in downtown Atlanta


    ATLANTA — One of the nation's largest domed stadiums has been destroyed in a scheduled implosion in downtown Atlanta.

    The Georgia Dome is destroyed in a scheduled implosion Monday, Nov. 20, 2017, in Atlanta. The dome was not only the former home of the Atlanta Falcons but also the site of two Super Bowls, 1996 Olympics Games events and NCAA basketball tournaments among other major events. [Associated Press]
  3. Rick and Tom podcast: As Jameis Winston faces another accusation, Bucs win with Ryan Fitzpatrick


    The Bucs win again behind backup quarterback Ryan Fitzpatrick and a defense that creates five turnovers against the Dolphins. In their latest podcast, Rick Stroud and Tom Jones break down the game, including …

    Jameis Winston cheers as middle linebacker Kwon Alexander  intercepts a pass during the first half of the Bucs' win over the Dolphins. [LOREN ELLIOTT   |   Times]
  4. Auto racing: Martin Truex captures Cup championship

    Auto racing

    HOMESTEAD — Martin Truex capped the most successful season of his journeyman career as NASCAR's champion.

    Martin Truex dominated NASCAR’s top series with eight wins and his first Cup championship.
  5. USF, UCF contribute to a first in football poll


    The new Associated Press football poll produced some Florida history Sunday.

    USF defenders celebrate a fourth-down stop during Thursday night’s victory over Tulsa. The No. 22 Bulls visit No. 13 UCF on Friday.